Can Small Businesses Charge Smokers More for Health Insurance?

Written by promotiondept

September 24, 2018

Last Updated: May 18, 2016
Health insurance costs are a huge portion of many small business’s budgets. One way they might seek to recoup some of those costs is by charging rs more for their insurance. But is that actually legal? Find out here.

Small business owners, feeling the financial strain of providing health insurance to employees, are looking for ways to cut costs. Some would like to pass some of the costs of an employee’s bad habits on to the employee but are you allowed? Take smoking, for example. Can you charge an employee that s more for their health insurance than one that doesn’t ?


The (Kind Of) Easy Answer

The answer to this question largely falls not under the Affordable Care Act but the older HIPAA laws. HIPPA doesn’t allow you to charge an employee a higher premium because of a health factor. Health factors are mostly what you would think—you can’t charge a disabled person a higher premium, for example. If you know that somebody was rectly diagnosed with something, you can’t raise their premium, and you can’t raise rates because you know that they spd a lot of time at the doctor.

You also can’t charge your thrill-seeker employee more. Maybe somebody rides a motorcycle to work every day, or they’re in to horseback riding, skydiving, or skiing. If you charged these people higher premiums you would be in violation of the law. It would seem that rs would fall into this.

But that’s not the whole story. HIPPA allows employers to “reward” non-smoking employees as long as the reward isn’t more than a 20% premium discount and the employer establishes a wellness program.

There are 4 other requiremts the employer must meet.

1. The program is reasonably deed to promote health and prevt disease.

2. Employees must have the opportunity to qualify for the reward at least once per year.

3. Employees who can’t stop smoking must be giv an alternative for qualifying—educational classes for example.

4. That alternative must be disclosed in the paperwork.

As long as you can satisfy those conditions, you can charge non-rs less than rs. You can read the Departmt of Labor’s guidelines here.

Not That Easy

It’s true that there is some leeway that allows it but small business owners have to ask themselves if it’s worth the possible legal challges. For businesses with a lot of employees and an established legal team the savings might outweigh the pottial costs of legal proceedings but if not, are you ready to deal with these problems?

First, the Americans with Disabilities Act prohibits discrimination against employees with disabilities. Smoking hasn’t be formally idtified as a disability but there are numerous “disabilities” that strongly correlate—COPD, emphysema, and lung cancer, to name a few.

Attorneys could argue that once smoking becomes a decades-long , quitting is no longer a matter of choice. Experts acknowledge that an argumt like that might be a stretch but there’s a strong that it would go to trial—costing the company a lot of money.

There are also state law concerns. The District of Columbia prohibits any discrimination against rs, for example. Other states and localities have similar laws. The small business owner has to carefully review laws in their area before implemting such a program.

Third, the cost of creating, running, and maintaining records related to a wellness program should be weighed against the pottial savings the program would create. There’s strong evidce that wellness programs make for healthier employees but small business owners that also serve as all-things-HR might not have the resources for the program.

See: for additional information.

Social Concerns

There are also intangible concerns that relate to employee morale and managemt. Are other employees expected to report people who are smoking out of sight of managemt? What about if they go out after work? Do they report behaviors tng place outside of work hours?

Is the report of another employee s for rescinding the reward or is there a due-process that includes an investigation?

How will you verify that employees are or are not free? Will you trust what they say? What happs if you later find out they lied on the paperwork? How about e-cigarettes—are people that use them considered rs or not?

Do you risk turning your work vironmt into one that is hostile toward rs if people know that they are indirectly paying for the r’s higher insurance premiums if left unreported?

These are just a few of the concerns that you will have to wade through if you decide to act a tiered system. Is the time and effort worth the hassle? That will largely depd on how many employees you have, whether or not you have an HR departmt, and other factors specific to your business.

However, there’s no doubt that having an employee wellness program is beficial ev if it isn’t specifically to address rs. Rewarding physical activity, healthy eating, and wellness exams will pay off over time not just for your employees, but also on your health insurance bill.

© 2016 Attard s, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced, reprinted or redistributed without writt permission from Attard s, Inc.



Happiness is for those who plan well and pursue. A profound among us have been proven those who have true dream to live for likely REALIZED IT. It is just simply the person working toward the DREAM days and night until accomplishment. There is a phrase of efficiency a head of you. Steps and obstacles at first seem tremendous. However, just with some times those difficult steps and challenges are so easy performance for you. There are also plenty of tools including VISUALIZATIONS and helps are around you.

You May Also Like…



  1. mortgage broker coquitlam - I found the best coquitlam mortgage broker. Chack out the best mortgage broker in Coquitlam BC.
  2. mortgage broker - I found the best Vancouver mortgage broker. Check out the best mortgage broker in Vancouver BC.
  3. mortgage broker richmond - I found the best Richmond Mortgage Broker. Check out the best mortgage broker in Richmond BC.

Submit a Comment