No Shortcuts to Social Success


Recently on one of the forums I frequent, we were discussing social bookmarking. One of the administrators pointed out that traffic from social bookmarking sites is generally transient, only sticking around for (at most) a few seconds and rarely converting. Besides, many such sites now routinely “nofollow” outbound links, so they don’t pass along “link juice,” either.

Whereupon a poster remarked that it appeared social bookmarking was a complete waste of time.

I hear that from some marketers, not just about social bookmarking but about social media in general. I’m not sure I’d be so quick to characterize it as a complete waste of time, though. It’s not so much that social bookmarking and social media doesn’t “work” as it is that some marketers seem to approach it all wrong.

Bad approach = bad results

Typically, what I hear from those who think social media is useless is: they make a list of the most popular social bookmarking sites, and every time they create a new article or blog post they mass-submit the page to all of them. Then they sit back and complain about the poor quality traffic and how the entire exercise doesn’t seem to bring much long-term benefit to their site.

Now, the way I look at it, it’s not so much about the direct traffic you get from the social bookmark site. In my opinion, here’s where the real value lies: social media submissions — if done well — have the potential to bring your pages to the attention of people who might be interested in what you have to say. And those interested people can prove useful.

The first commandment: be interesting

Perhaps someone will see your page link on that social bookmarking site, be intrigued and visit it, find it informative or entertaining and link to it or write about it (or both) on their site, thereby encouraging their visitors to check you out. At the very least, they’ll vote it up in the social bookmark site itself, thereby helping bring your content to the attention of others and increasing the possibility of someone finding it useful enough to highlight on their own site or blog.

In other words, social media can lead to “real” links (that is: the kind that aren’t nofollowed) and “real” traffic (that is: the kind that sticks around to buy stuff).

The key bit in that is that the people who see your stuff on a social site have to find it intriguing enough to visit, vote up and/or link to and/or write about. Which means wholesale submitting every new page you create to vast numbers of social sites without regard for the relevance of that page to each site’s audience is simply not a productive strategy. It’s the easy way, it’s the way a lot of marketers seem to approach social bookmarking, but it just doesn’t work.

Focus, focus, focus

Each social site has its own focus. Some are all about breaking news, some about women’s issues, some about technology or politics or marketing or arts-and-crafts or kids’ activities or whatever. Some are filled with edgy or controversial content, while others are more mainstream. You need to explore each site you’re considering deeply enough to make sure you have a good handle on the kinds of things that will appeal to the “citizens” of that site.

Think “niche.” Try to identify as many bookmark sites as you can that relate to your business/industry — these may not be the “big guns” of the social bookmarking world, but they’ll be much more likely to be receptive to what you submit.

Start by making sure your submissions aren’t just your own stuff. Be generous to a fault. Try for at least a ten-to-one ratio of other people’s stuff to your own — and make sure you’ve already got a good, balanced submission history before you submit the first page from your own site.

You don’t want to get known as one of the spammers who only drops in to submit his/her own pages (and mostly irrelevant pages at that). That’s a quick way to get ignored by alot of people. You don’t want to be ignored. The key term in social media is… well… social.

Get by with a little help from your friends

In other words, it’s all about exposure. You need friends on the social site to visit, recommend or vote up your pages. If they do, their other friends may then be exposed to your content, which they in turn can visit and pass along to their friends, and so on and so forth. Most of them will probably just visit quickly and leave, but a few may stick around… find your site useful… link to you.

But if you’ve self-identified yourself as a link dropping spammer, you’re not going to have many friends (and even fewer influential friends). No friends, no recommendations, little exposure. Simple as that.

Beyond that, be selective about what you submit. When you have content that is especially interesting, newsworthy or relevant to that particular site’s topic, submit it. But be aware, not every new bit of content you create is worthy of submitting. Just the super-relevant really good stuff. (And be honest with yourself — there’s no way every page on your site is “the good stuff.”)

It may even turn out you submit different pages to different sites. Perhaps you have a somewhat irreverent, humorous blog post that’s perfect for one social site, and a scholarly serious article on your main website that’s ideal for another. So submit the pages to the site(s) where they “belong.” Don’t just willy-nilly submit everything to everybody. You want to target each submission to the site(s) where it’s most likely to do well.

Is this more work than just “carpet bombing” every social site you can find with every new post or article you create? You betcha.

But, ya know, nobody ever said taking the easy way out is a shortcut to success.

Learn more about the ways Diane can help improve the performance and profitability of your business web site, or request a no-obligation personal consultation, by visiting

Thanks for the information. I never thought about social bookmarking in the “niche” sort of way until I read your post.

Hi Diane,

This is a very thoughtful post. Totally right on about the effects of Social Media. And to think nothing is ever instant. Those who mass submit and self-promote don’t get that they are not being social and that social media involves making friends and creating and sharing content that is super valuable. Right on, girl!

I appreciate you.
Dali Burgado

Good point, Diane. Focus is crucial in social media campaings just like in any marketing activities. You need to stay focused all the time: when picking the keywords for your SEO or PPC, when choosing the topic for your blog post, etc. The challenge is not to get overwhelmed by big traffic but to concentrate on people who really care about what you have to say or offer. Thanks for reminding us about it.

Great article, when you start doing social media work you can see that your site get up at SERP. Social Media work goes on with SEO work so when ever you do one of them the other one get the push.

I completely agree with you, Diane. Though I myself experienced somewhat “bad” and temporary results with social bookmarking but later I realized that my approach wasn’t good enough. You put some great points there. We can surely get the most out of social bookmarking if we just use it the smart way.. the right way..

A truly thoughtful and value post πŸ™‚

Sunita Biddu

It’s a numbers game and you need the numbers (“friends”) to get it out there. You can either become a social media power user or become very very good friends with some.

One day businesses will realize that everyone is fed up with being bombarded with targeted advertising intruding in their lives. The future is to be where consumers look when they’re ready to buy.

I think, Social networking gives some what positive effect in SERP. So though it takes time, one should do smart work over there. surely niche is important.Your suggestions for proper approach to social bookmark is really good.thank you.

Social marketing is still one of the best ways to promote your site, it’s been around for a while and will be around much much more, better start getting used to it.

Thanks, everyone for your comments!

@Dali, I appreciate you, too. πŸ™‚

@SEO guy, yep it is hard to remember focus when so often we (and clients) obsess over getting lots of traffic. It’s so cool to see huge traffic numbers, but it’s better to get a smaller number of highly interested visitors than a tsunami of 5-second-and-out bounce traffic.

@Frugalocal, so very true!

@Phoenix Car Bulbs, you’re absolutely right — social bookmarking is all about give and take. Those who only take will lose out in the end.

Social bookmarking is still the powertool for SEO as what i have noticed in my past 3 years of experience. I have achieved good results to my clients just by doing social bookmarking in small intervals.

Good point. Social media does work but takes a creative approach tailored to one’s unique goal.

I think that things like Social Bookmarking is mainly targeted at individuals not businesses. However, I believe if companies use tools like this in the right way, they can get huge success from them.

Links from social media sites carry beyond the link power a certain amount of credibility when you make intelligent thought provoking comments.

I use social bookmaking to supplement our link building efforts for our clients and to vary the target anchor text, but on its own it could not deliver top ranking for very competitive keyword terms. At least this is what my experience had been.

You are right Diane, in order to make Social Networking actually work, you have to be Social. Participate in what is going on and get involved with the people that’s on there.
Once they start to warm up to you, then they might check out your profile and take a look at your blog.

You’re right. We need focus, and don’t forget, we need patience too πŸ™‚

Read by small business people, our newsletter delivers a digest of articles from the top search engine marketing experts. You will learn about:

Our newsletter is the perfect way to stay up to date with all of the latest trends, events and techniques in using search engines to grow your business and make more sales. Subscribe here. Your email address will NOT be given to third parties.

FreeFind Site Search Engine – FreeFind adds a “search this site” feature to your website, making your site easier to use. FreeFind also gives you reports showing what your visitors are searching for, enabling you to improve your site. FreeFind’s advanced site search engine and automatic site map technology can be added to your website for free.

Buy UPC Codes
Get your products listed online!

Search marketing information for small business owners.

Fetching the best small business news.

A friendly place to share small business ideas and knowledge.

Small business support through education, resources and community

The directory of the best small business sites and tools.


Research & References of No Shortcuts to Social Success|A&C Accounting And Tax Services

Leave a Reply